Members Login
Username 
 
Password 
    Remember Me  
Post Info TOPIC: Suggestions for utility players


Cult Status

Status: Offline
Posts: 290
Date:
Suggestions for utility players


As suggested by FA - a thread for people to suggest valid utility players. However, I think it is important to remember two things.

Firstly that players such as midfielders who attack (such as Gerrard) are already covered by their stats i.e. midfielders with attacking emphasis or defensive emphasis in their stats, and the same goes for strikers who can play wide e.g. Bellamy.

Also that people remember we are not talking about players who get told to play somewhere by the manager because the team are desperate, but a player who can give a good account of themselves in more than one position. For those old enough to remember - Paul Madeley of Leeds was one of the originals, and at the time was often listed as such because there were hardly any utility players in the British game.

I'll start things off with a few suggestions:

Jamie Carragher of Liverpool - either CB or FB (he's played both left and right). He's not as good in all of these positions but is recognised as someone who can play either.

Gary Neville of Man. Utd. - either FB or CB (he spent much of the season before last covering as CB for Man. Utd. because Fergy kept buying strikers when he needed to by defenders!).

Joe Ledley of Cardiff - either CM or FB (he has played at LB for both Cardiff and Wales).

Possibly Michael Essien of Chelsea - he's a CM but spent much of last season at CB (but then he was pretty crap at it so perhaps he shouldn't count!).

Anyway, that should start the ball rolling.
Steve
Cardiff

-- Edited by Steve at 21:59, 2007-07-31

__________________


Cult Status

Status: Offline
Posts: 1414
Date:

Flamini - Arsenal (now at Man City)

played both LB and CM. 1 season in the premiership and 2 in the reserve at leftback and the rest of his career at cm should see decent stats in both areas - he was a very accomplished leftback and always looked comfortable

Ronaldinho - Barcelona

Accomplished on the LW, in midfield and as a stiker - but perhaps best as an attacking forward of midfielder

William Gallas - Arsenal

Accomplished at CB, LB and RB. Played mostly at leftback, but masses of games all along the back 4. Now plays regularly at Arsenal (real life) at centreback - his preffered choice

Ashley Young - Aston Villa

Great young winger - but played well as a forward for Watford for 2 seasons and one in the reserves playing upfront

Ledley King - Tottenham

Played both for club and country as a defensive midfielder aswell as centre back for club and country. Plays well as both in general



__________________

Man City Manager - English Premiership
simonnewcombe@googlemail.com



Cult Status

Status: Offline
Posts: 2308
Date:

Steve wrote:

Firstly that players such as midfielders who attack (such as Gerrard) are already covered by their stats i.e. midfielders with attacking emphasis or defensive emphasis in their stats, and the same goes for strikers who can play wide e.g. Bellamy.

Also that people remember we are not talking about players who get told to play somewhere by the manager because the team are desperate, but a player who can give a good account of themselves in more than one position. For those old enough to remember - Paul Madeley of Leeds was one of the originals, and at the time was often listed as such because there were hardly any utility players in the British game.


The first point is true. A midfielder who is good at attacking will have a good attack rating so thats taken into consideration already. The same for defensive midfielders and so on. It's unlikely a player will have utility positions such as the following; CM/ST, CB/CM, for these reasons.

The second point quoted applies to players given 'free roles' in the team. An example has already cropped up in my opinion in Ronaldinho. Ronaldinho is rarely put out on the wing but often drifts there from his central starting free role for both club and country.

So other than special cases, utility players will tend to be sideways eg. centre and right, or centre and left, rather than forwards or backwards eg. defender and midfielder or midfielder and striker.

Apart from that most of the names mentioned are on the right lines. If anyone else wants to contribute names they'll go towards forming a final list for the near future.

Richard.



__________________


Cult Status

Status: Offline
Posts: 464
Date:

The only slight problem with doing this is that not many people including myself would know which players of the Serie B teams would be utility players - as I guess not many people would watch Serie B!

Perhaps FA would be best to look at such teams?

Cheers JD Chievo

__________________


 



Cult Status

Status: Offline
Posts: 2308
Date:

I'll be checking the sites and databases I use for player data to collect the more obscure players so all leagues will be covered. It's easier if people put forward names for the more well known clubs. Chievo won't be forgotten about.

Richard.

__________________
Page 1 of 1  sorted by
Quick Reply

Please log in to post quick replies.

Tweet this page Post to Digg Post to Del.icio.us


Create your own FREE Forum
Report Abuse
Powered by ActiveBoard